SmartReply

Facebook AI Comment Analysis

Find a Facebook page to generate a comment analysis for. Note this free version only works with organic, if you would like to run a larger report, or include ads you must make an account.

← Back

Athena Club

Comment Analysis Report

Health/beauty

Data from Dec 16, 2025 to May 27, 2026

22,041

Followers

Comments

Grade

71.4

Score

Visit Website

Total Comments

Posts Analyzed

Top Level Comments

71.4/100

Overall Score

Brand Engagement ⓘ

User Comments

Categorized

❤️

176

Total Likes

📊

1.9

Avg Likes/Post

💬

0.9

Avg Comments/Post

🚀

2.8

Total Eng./Post

Sentiment Distribution

Negative (0%)

Neutral (52.11%)

Positive (47.89%)

Score Breakdown

Positive Comments 34 comments

D 47.89%

Neutral Comments 37 comments

C 52.11%

Negative Comments 0 comments

A 0%

Brand Engagement Rate 5 brand replies + 0 brand likes

F 6.17%

General Analysis

The user comments reveal a strong positive sentiment toward the fragrance products with enthusiasm for different scents and product types. Customers express desires for expanding product lines such as body washes and stick deodorants, as well as interest in retail availability and international shipping. Many comments show appreciation for cruelty-free practices and the emotional connections scents evoke. There are numerous requests for help or information, which classify as neutral, while a significant number of comments express excitement, love, and readiness to purchase or promote products. Very few comments do not fit into these categories due to off-topic content or unclear messages.

Customer Avatar

AI-derived from top posts + audience comments

Primary Avatar

Health Beauty Decision Makers

Recent comments show active interest, questions, and buying signals from people evaluating whether the brand is credible and relevant to them.

Market Sophistication

Level 3

The Athena Club audience has some awareness and is looking for proof, clarity, and a reason to trust the offer.

Core Desires

Highlight cruelty-free and ethical product Emphasize nostalgic and emotional connecti Promote full product sets for a complete f Leverage customer excitement and anticipat

Sub-Avatars

Research-Oriented Buyers

People comparing options who need credible details, proof, and clear next steps before engaging.

Solution Seekers

People with a specific need or frustration who respond to practical education and reassurance.

Summary

This fallback avatar was built from the classified comment data so the report remains complete when the optional AI avatar step is skipped for time.

📊

Comment Breakdown

📌 Posts Checked 92

💬 Total Comments 86

✅ With Text 71

💡 Page Replies 5

🙋 User Replies 81

🎯

Pain Points

1 Limited availability of desired product formats like body wash and stick deodorant

2 Customers wanting specific scents in multiple product types

3 Demand for international shipping or availability (e.g., UK)

4 Customers seeking retail location availability

5 Curiosity about scent longevity

💡

Marketing Angles

1 Highlight cruelty-free and ethical product testing

2 Emphasize nostalgic and emotional connections to scents

3 Promote full product sets for a complete fragrance experience

4 Leverage customer excitement and anticipation in promotions

5 Utilize affiliate marketing opportunities

Top Organic Posts

Posts ranked by most comments

6 Posts

VIDEO

Jan 29, 2026

✨MIST GIVEAWAY ✨ It’s time to find your signature scent. We’re giving away 5 complete sets from our Wardrobe of Scents — each box includes all 8 of our new Hair & Body Mists for you to explore, layer, and accessorize with. Love Letter– Velvety Iris, Pink Pepper, Creamy Woods Golden Vanilla– Vanilla Cream, Cashmere, Sandalwood Salted Sunset– Caramel, Coconut Milk, Pistachio Amber Hours– Creamy Gardenia, Vanilla, Amber Petal Bloom– Rose Water, Peony Petals, Lychee Super Pink– Mandarin, Island Orchid, Vanilla Solar Muse– Bergamot, Neroli Blossom, Frangipani First Blush– Juicy Pear, Honeysuckle, Sandalwood To enter: ✔️Follow us on Instagram + TikTok ✔️Like this post ✔️Tag your bestie that always smells good Giveaway ends 2/2 at 11:59 PM PST. T&C’s: No purchase necessary. Must be a U.S. resident + 18+ to enter. Winner will only be contacted by @athenaclub—never anyone else!

26 comments

17 likes

View on Facebook

VIDEO

Jan 27, 2026

@paulreactss meets our eight new scents for the very first time. Which are you most excited to layer? Collect them all now on athenaclub.com.

10 comments

25 likes

View on Facebook

VIDEO

Feb 9, 2026

☁️ GIVEAWAY ☁️ We’re calling it our Winter Wardrobe (of scent). Featuring: Love Letter– Velvety Iris, Pink Pepper, Creamy Woods Golden Vanilla– Vanilla Cream, Cashmere, Sandalwood Salted Sunset– Caramel, Coconut Milk, Pistachio Amber Hours– Creamy Gardenia, Vanilla, Amber Think cozy cashmere, warm sandalwood, soft sweetness and a hint of spice that will carry you through the season. And this one’s for you 🫶 We’re giving away 5 of our mailers to our community to help you perfect your winter layers. To enter: ✔️Follow us on Instagram + TikTok ✔️Like this post ✔️Tag your bestie that always smells good Giveaway ends 2/13 at 11:59 PM PST. T&C’s: No purchase necessary. Must be a U.S. resident + 18+ to enter. Winner will only be contacted by @athenaclub—never anyone else!

5 comments

9 likes

View on Facebook

VIDEO

Feb 23, 2026

(No text content — media post)

3 comments

0 likes

View on Facebook

VIDEO

Apr 23, 2026

(No text content — media post)

2 comments

0 likes

View on Facebook

VIDEO

Feb 17, 2026

Love Letter + Golden Vanilla = Vanilla Crush. ☁️ Made for layering, each fragrance is an instant mood boost — fun, expressive, and easy. No rules, no designer price tag. Just a scent that feels like you. Find your match at athenaclub.com

2 comments

6 likes

View on Facebook

Negative Comments

No negative comments found.

Neutral Comments

Post ID	Comment	Date
View Post	Need Solar Muse in a Body Wash, please!	1 month ago
View Post	Does this scent have a body wash too?	4 weeks ago
View Post	Please make the stick deodorant and body wash in Amber Hours	1 month ago
View Post	I couldn’t find the body mist on your website	3 months ago
View Post	Athena Club are they sold in Target?	3 months ago
View Post	Carlus Mcdougle	3 months ago
View Post	I have a really cute onesie I bought from Shein with the same exact lip prints all over it and its white..your outfit reminded me of it 💋💋💋	2 months ago
View Post	How can I get this set?	1 month ago
View Post	Carlus Mcdougle	3 months ago
View Post	Francisco Aguilar-lopez	3 months ago
View Post	I don’t have IG or TT. But I followed this page 😁 Anna Clifton Roberts	3 months ago
View Post	Madalynn Ankney	3 months ago
View Post	Hailey MaeLynn Ashley Keffer	4 months ago
View Post	William Cohl	4 months ago
View Post	Lillie Fisher	4 months ago
View Post	Nikki Eggers	4 months ago
View Post	Britney Grace Kelly Keurig	4 months ago
View Post	Francisco Aguilar-lopez	4 months ago
View Post	💝💘 Brittany Jo	4 months ago
View Post	Pam Harrington 💝💘	4 months ago
View Post	Dorothy Anne Hagberg 💝💘	4 months ago
View Post	Nana Thompson 💝💘	4 months ago
View Post	💝💘 Hanna Giles	4 months ago
View Post	💝💘 Lilly Mae	4 months ago
View Post	💝💘 Brittany Raisor	4 months ago
View Post	Teresa Kunberger 💝💘	4 months ago
View Post	Kelli Krzyzanski-Boggio 💝💘	4 months ago
View Post	Laura A Bailey 💝💘	4 months ago
View Post	Anne Carstensen 💝💘	4 months ago
View Post	💝💘 Sherry Barnes	4 months ago
View Post	💝💘 Tina Brandel	4 months ago
View Post	💝💘 Karen Smith	4 months ago
View Post	Do they last long ?	4 months ago
View Post	Does anyone know if these are sold in stores?	4 months ago
View Post	Luscious❤️	4 months ago
View Post	Where to buy?	5 months ago
View Post	بكام	5 months ago

Positive Comments

Post ID	Comment	Date
View Post	I can’t wait to try this out	3 weeks ago
View Post	Salted sunset and solar muse are so good	4 weeks ago
View Post	Solar Museum is my favorite!! It’s reminds me of the beach when I was a kid. 🥰	1 month ago
View Post	Thank you for not testing on animals 🙏	1 month ago
View Post	That is the best	1 month ago
View Post	I bet this night smelt unreal 🥰😍	2 months ago
View Post	I need the WHOLE SET	1 month ago
View Post	😍 please send some perfume to the UK. Pleeeaaase!!! 🥺🥺	2 months ago
View Post	My two favorites, by far! Thanks for sharing this!	1 month ago
View Post	I would love to be an affiliate for Athena Club 🥰 these products are amazing	3 months ago
View Post	Golden Vanilla is scrumptious. Can’t get enough.	3 months ago
View Post	✨	3 months ago
View Post	✨	3 months ago
View Post	✨ ✨✨	3 months ago
View Post	My favorite!! 🤎	3 months ago
View Post	Absolutely love this pair ♥️😍✔️	3 months ago
View Post	okay a total need! these sound amazing so many beautiful notes! I would be so proud to wear these beautiful fragrances 🤍☺️ Eric Hoeppner	3 months ago
View Post	I need em all	3 months ago
View Post	Dillan Clark😍😍	4 months ago
View Post	Woah	4 months ago
View Post	Signed up for your email 💘💝	4 months ago
View Post	WOW WHAT A GREAT GIVEAWAY 💝💘 THIS INCREDIBLE 👏..I LOVE PERFUME 💨 AND LOVE TRYING NEW ONES LITTLE SAMPLES BEFORE I BUY THEM ❤️..THESE LOOK AHHMAZZZZING 😍 AND I WOULD LOVE SO MUCH TO HAVE THIS WONDERFUL OPPORTUNITY TO WIN 💘❤️ ...I WOULD BE OVER THR 🌙 AND BEYOND...TO BE SO LUCKY 🍀💯🙏🏽 ...YOU GUYS ARE AWESOME THANK YOU SOOOOO VERY MUCH FOR YOUR KINDNESS AND GENEROSITY I'M VERY GRATEFUL 💯 FOLLOWER.. HERE AND INSTAGRAM TOOK SCREENSHOTS...I DONT USE ANY OTHER PLATFORMS ...LOVED POST..SHARED WITH LOTS AND TAGGED LOTS OF FRIENDS SEPARATELY GOOD LUCK TO ALL 🍀 DONE ✔️	4 months ago
View Post	Omg they answered my prayers 😂 I've been asking for months and months for body mists! Also more fruity scents with the shave creams, lotions, and body washes 😍 I'm probably the only one who can't stand vanilla and floral scents 😩	4 months ago
View Post	Awesome!!!	4 months ago
View Post	Salted sunset is that girl	3 months ago
View Post	I was buying the lotion a couple days ago now I bought body spray and the oil body wash omg I’m So looking forward to the almond creme! I can’t wait	4 months ago
View Post	About time! Love your shave oils. Can’t wait to try.	4 months ago
View Post	I love this lotion	1 week ago
View Post	You guys are ahhmazzzzing..they must last a long time 💝	4 months ago
View Post	Love letters	4 months ago
View Post	I love perfume 💝	4 months ago
View Post	Can’t wait!	4 months ago
View Post	I need to try these! 🙌	4 months ago
View Post	YAAAY! CAN'T WAIT!!!	4 months ago